Contact Us

white text on blue background reads "Whom do I contact with questions regarding?"

The Monticello Central School District believes that open communication is key to building relationships with our families. Contacting the appropriate person or department for your specific situation will help expedite your response. Please click the image above, or click this link to learn who can best help you resolve your issue, or answer your question.

Staff Directory

Search for individual faculty and staff by typing ONE of these options in the box below: first name, last name, email or building. To search by department (i.e. guidance, nurse, etc.) please use the web search function at the top right hand side of each web page. 

Tip: If you don’t know how to spell the name of the person you are looking for, try typing the first few letters of their first or last name and click ‘Go’.


Monticello Central School District Administrative Office

Monticello Central School District
60 Jefferson Street, Suite 3
Monticello, NY 12701
Hours: 8 a.m. – 4 p.m.
Phone: 845-794-7700
Fax: (845) 794-7710

Matthew T. Evans, Ed.D.
Superintendent of Schools
845-794-7700, ext. 70910 

Beth Culligan 
Administrative Specialist to the Superintendent
845-794-7700, ext. 70511

Lisa Failla 
Assistant Superintendent for Business 
845-794-7700, ext. 70525

Cindy Sapia
Administrative Specialist 
845-794-7700 ext 70501

Theresa Carlin
Assistant Superintendent for Curriculum and Instruction
845-794-7700, ext. 10912

Martha Tully
Administrative Specialist
845-794-7700, ext. 70536

Shannon Leaney-Levenson
Executive Director of Data, Assessment, and Human Resources
845-794-7700, ext. 70534

Erinn Morse
Educational Data Manager
845-794-7700, ext. 70535

Keith Petzinger
Director of Elementary Education
845-794-7700, ext. 70538

Monticello CSD Business Office 

60 Jefferson Street, Suite 3
Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: 845-794-7702
Fax: 845-794-7718

Elizabeth Terwilliger
845-794-7700, ext. 70526

Jean Jaffee 
Benefits, Attendance and Payroll
845-794-7700, ext. 70544

Lisa SagerFarr
845-794-7700, ext. 70541

Ann-Marie Foss 
District Clerk
845-794-7700, ext. 70523

Virginia Palmer
Tax Collector/Deputy Treasurer
845-794-7700, ext. 70599

Monticello High School 

39 Breakey Avenue
Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: 845-794-8840

Robert J. Kaiser Middle School

45 Breakey Avenue
Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: 845-796-3058 

St. John Street Community School 

22 St. John Street
Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: 845-796-5095 ext. 95233 

Emma C. Chase Elementary School

28 Pennsylvania Avenue
Wurtsboro, NY 12790
Phone: 845-888-2471

George L. Cooke Elementary School

69 Richardson Avenue
Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: 845-794-8830
Fax: (845) 794-8854

Kenneth L. Rutherford Elementary School

26 Patricia Place
Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: 845-794-4240

Communications, Media and Website Management

Courtney Bonfante
District Public Information Officer
Public Relations, Media Inquiries, District Communications
T: 845-794-7700, ext. 70531

Feedback Form

Use the form below to send us your feedback, comments or questions.